one of the first things i changed out after picking up my 2017 jcw, was the manual shift knob. while the jcw knob looks great and elegant, it always felt very awkward in my hand. i was initially looking at the cravenspeed ones, but then found and glad i got a raceseng one (prolix-brushed). yes, they are pricey, but the quality and heft (very weighty) are incredible. this shifter weighs about 1.5 lbs. since i had the jcw shifter, the boot was to short, so i had to purchase the regular length boot to get this to work (was pretty easy popping out the old one and installing the replacement in the shifter ring). shifting now feels really good and love the look too. i definitely now want to swap out the shifter to a short-throw one for an even greater shifting experience.